Enforcing Net Neutrality: A continuous monitoring challenge


New Delhi, 20thJuly, 2015- The Indian Legal Foundation (TILF) in association with Grandmasters India conducted a Brainstorming and Forum Discussion in India Habitat Center, Lodhi Road, New Delhi. This day-long session focused on the various aspects of Net Neutrality.


As the Department of Telecom (DoT) panel lead by Shri A.K. Bhargava released its report on Net Neutrality, there still remained concerns among the Free Internet proponents about the enforcement of Principles of Net Neutrality.  The DoT panel suggestions on enforcing Net Neutrality included enacting a law, amending Licensing Conditions, creating a DoT monitoring cell and also creating training institutions to monitor Net Neutrality violations. However, all of these seem to be soft approaches for bigger violations that impact Principles of Net Neutrality.  There seems to be no recommendations on quantum of penalty or punishments in case of deliberate violations on Net Neutrality.


These were some of the concerns aired during well attended Think Tank Meeting with participants from Corporates, Government, Politics, NGOs and Startups.  “While we appreciate the overall intent of DoT report, but where does it talk about penalties, like we saw in the recent AT & T case in United States” asked Renu Jha, Chairperson, Government Affairs, The Indian Legal Foundation (“TILF”) – a New Delhi based Think Tank organization. Renu further mentioned, “We need to create a regulatory body with powers to impose fine and punishments. It is a necessary step towards creating and regulating Net Neutrality in India”


While welcoming DoT recommendations, Mr. Rajendra Sharma, General Counsel, Samsung said “That there still needs to be a lot of work in creating an appropriate legislation around the governance of Internet in India. We need to incorporate best practices from EU and United States to ensure freedom of Internet in India”.


The Think Tank Event was presided over by Shri Tarun Vijay, Member of Parliament, Rajya Sabha who is among the most vocal proponents of Free Internet in India and has equated net neutrality to Human Rights of Digital Age. “Net Neutrality is core and essential to the government program on Skill Development, Digital India and Make In India. Government and Indian parliament is committed to Net Neutrality. Any apprehension on recent DOT recommendation will be debated and government will fight for democracy of Internet” said Shri Tarun Vijay.



The event was also marked by number of startups concerned about their growth in case Telcos are allowed to disseminate discriminatory tariffs or bandwidth to users. “Will it not be a classic case of crony capitalism if startup applications are discriminated as they are unable to cuff up extra bug for Telcos” asked Yogesh Kochar, a social media start up for school students in India.  Renu agreeing with young startup entrepreneurs stated, “India is hub of startups for quality software and mobile applications. Any pricing or accessibility discrimination against newer applications by Telcos will certainly kill their growth and stifle innovation”.

The Government’s hypothesis needs to be supported – “Good” regulations are better than “No” regulations at all. We do not want Indian Government or DoT to be silent on this important subject. If they remain silent and do not positively support Net Neutrality, ISPs on a later date can disrupt access to websites that do not pay them or compete with their interests. Indeed, the survival of Internet depends on DoT and Government of India and it’s implementation and enforcement of principles of Net Neutrality.


About TILF

TILF is an incorporated body under section 25 of the Companies Act, 1956 (now Section 8 of the Company Act, 2013) as a not-for-profit, non-governmental and non-political organization which is supported by the Legal Community in India and abroad. With the help of this support TILF has been able to garner subscription from Leading Advocates, Attorneys, Former Judges, Multinational Corporate & Businesses, Law Firms, Legal Fraternity and Professionals, Senior Government Officials, Law Students and Professors, NGOs, Litigants, Law Publishers and Vendors, Groups, Associations, and Individuals who are interested in promoting the goals and objectives of the Foundation.

About Grandmasters India

Grandmasters India is an initiative to foster and promote multidimensional domains of knowledge in diverse categories of people in age, languages, industries etc.  It’s current focus is on Management, Leadership and Law.


They believe in upgrading the knowledge repertoire of people by practical and interactive practices and aim for bridging the gap between Mentors, sources, platforms and learners audience.